Many of us spend a great deal of time getting our makeup just right, and there's nothing worse than finishing a perfect masterpiece on your eyes, only to have it crease, fade, or smudge an hour later. To keep your eye makeup lasting longer and ensuring it sticks to your lids and doesn't stray, the best eyeshadow primers will keep your eye shadow vibrant and locked in place.

So what's the big deal about primer? There are many primers on the market and they're better than ever. The best eyeshadow primers are stronger and more effective than before and do much more than just prime the eyes. If you're considering adding a primer into your makeup routine or are just interested in learning what's so great about them and how they're applied, read on. This article will cover all of those topics and more. Consider our best eyeshadow primer list for 2019 and get updated.

Best Eyeshadow Primer FAQ

1. What Is Eyeshadow Primer?

Primer is not just for makeup artists. Many consumers are buying and applying primers with great result. Many use primers before applying makeup to both their face and eyes. The main difference between eye primer and face primer is the formula. Eye primers feel slightly sticker and have more grip to help make your shadow and eyeliner last much longer.

In a nutshell, eyeshadow primer is a liquid- or cream-based product applied on the eyelids to make shadows and eyeliner apply smoothly and last longer. It serves as an adhesive that holds onto your eyeshadow and makeup, making sure it doesn't stray. It also enhances the color of your makeup and makes it last much longer.

2. What Does Eyeshadow Primer Do?

The best eyeshadow primers on the market will ensure your shadow or liquid eyeliner stays locked in place all day. It will also prevent your shadow from creasing on your eyelids. The best eyeshadow primers come in a gel formula that quickly spreads over your eyelid when blending.

3. How Does Eyeshadow Primer Work?

Just like a face primer, it helps to hold makeup in place for longer than it otherwise would stay. You will apply eyeshadow primer under concealer or shadow. Its adhesive formula will ensure that your eye makeup will completely hold in place all day without smudging or creasing.

4. Where Can You Buy Eyeshadow Primer?

You can buy eyeshadow primer online at Amazon, department stores, or any local makeup and beauty stores.

How We Reviewed

We've reviewed the best eyeshadow primers on the market for 2019 and compared their price points, consumer reviews, benefits, and durability to compile the following list. These products are some of most popular amongst consumers and makeup artists. We think you'll enjoy our unbiased review of these products to help you decide on a great primer.

Overall Price Range of This Product (and Similar Products)

Eyeshadow primers range as low as $5 upwards of $10, depending on the brand and formula benefits (and ingredients). However, regardless of the price, many of these eye primers are great products. So, let's take a look.

 

What We Reviewed

  • NYX Professional Makeup Eyeshadow Base
  • Too Faced Shadow Insurance Anti-Crease Eye Shadow Primer
  • e.l.f. Eye Primer and Liner Sealer
  • Elizabeth Mott Thank Me Later Eyeshadow Primer
  • bareMinerals Prime Time Eye Primer
  • Mary Kay Eye Primer
  • Urban Decay, Eyeshadow Primer Potion Tube
  • LORAC Behind The Scenes Eye Shadow Primer
  • Laura Mercier Eye Basics
  • Smashbox Photo Finish Shadow Primer
NYX Professional Makeup Eyeshadow Base, White, 0.25 Ounce
  • NYX Cosmetics Eye Shadow Base
  • White
  • NYX Cosmetics

Features

NYX Eye Shadow Base competes with the most expensive brands. You only need a small amount to cover the entire eyelid, and it applies easily with the included applicator wand. This primer will keep your shadow and eyeliner in place all day and will prevent smudging due to moisture. This eye shadow primer also helps prevent your lids from getting oily, which will also help keep your eye makeup colorful and preserved. It runs at an affordable price and is a great quality product.

NYX Eye Shadow Base is a white base for all skin types including sensitive skin. Most consumers with sensitive skin love that this primer will not cause the eyes to sting at all. Because it is a white base, it will make eye makeup look more intense and vibrant. A small amount of this primer goes a long way and will make your eyeshadow pop.

Pros

  • Great price
  • Great for sensitive skin
  • Prevents smudging due to moisture

Cons

  • May not last as long as other products on the market
  • price

This product can be found on Amazon for around from $4.19 to 7.00.

 

Too Faced Shadow Insurance Anti-Crease Eye Shadow Primer 0.35 OZ
  • Long Wearing Unique color binders guarantee your shadows never crease, smudge or fade
  • Vitamin E - Conditions, soothes and calms the delicate eye area
  • Unique Binders - Volatiles lock down eye shadow pigments for amazingly long wear

Features

Too Faced Shadow Insurance Anti-Crease Shadow Primer is one of the best eyeshadow primers on the market. It prevents fallout, fading, and creasing. It is a silicone-based primer that will create a barrier between your makeup and any oil or moisture. This primer is ideal for oily eyelids. Your shadow and eyeliner will blend evenly and smoothly, giving your color vibrant results.

This primer from Too Faced is just as good as its signature formula, and the product reviews reveal that consumers love it. A little goes a long way; you only need a drop for complete eyelid coverage and a flawless, maximized shadow pigment.

Pros

  • Locks down eyeshadow for long wear
  • Guarantee shadow never creases, smudges, or fades
  • Conditions, soothes, and calms the delicate skin

Cons

  • It's less affordable than other options
  • Feels slightly greasy on application
  • price

This product can be found on Amazon for around from $19.00 to $22.00.

e.l.f. Cosmetics Eye Primer & Liner Sealer, Keeps Eyeshadow and...
  • KEEP YOUR MAKEUP IN PLACE - Our convenient, dual-ended Eye Primer and Liner Sealer stick provides everything you'll need...
  • PRIME YOUR EYES - The eye primer acts as an ideal base for eyeshadow application. This primer creates the perfect canvas...
  • SEAL YOUR LINER - Turn your eyeliner waterproof in an instant with the Liner Sealer. This sealer locks down eyeliner and...

Features

e.l.f Eye Primer and Liner Sealer is a well-established eyeshadow primer for many people. It's affordable and very effective. Your shadow will lock in place all day, and it will prevent your shadow from smudging. The e.l.f primer will keep your shadow color vibrant. If you're looking for an eyeshadow primer that performs like other popular primers on the market and is a great price, this is it.

Pros

  • Prime side sets shadow so its color won't fade, smudge, or crease
  • Waterproof, smudge-proof liquid liner
  • Clear liquid with a built-in precision eyeliner brush

Cons

  • Primer may feel a slightly firm
  • A little difficult to apply
  • price

This product can be found on Amazon for around from $7.99 to $10.00

Eye Primer Makeup Eyeshadow Base: Elizabeth Mott Thank Me Later Eye...
  • LONG LASTING: Our long wear eye base locks in and enhances your shadow color for a flawless look
  • QUICK DRYING: The transparent eyeshadow base dries in seconds for a smooth, crease free application
  • BRIGHTENS AND BALANCES: The pearl powder evens and brightens your skin tone while combating oiliness

Features

Elizabeth Mott Thank Me Later Eyeshadow Primer is a highly reviewed, high-customer satisfaction eyeshadow primer. It is one of the best eyeshadow primers available on the market. A quick look at their Amazon reviews will help you understand why. It is a transparent primer that locks in shadows all day. It's great for all skin types—most notably oily skin. It's also a cruelty-free brand, which makes this product even better!

Pros

  • Preps your lids for a smooth, even application
  • Great for oily skin
  • Elizabeth Mott is a cruelty-free brand
  • Offers a product satisfaction guarantee

Cons

  • Chalky texture
  • May reduce the sheen of certain shadows
  • Has a slightly matting effect
  • price

This product can be found on Amazon for around from $13.06 to $16.00.

bareMinerals Prime Time Eye Primer, Original, 0.1 Ounce
  • Works overtime so that you enjoy vibrant, lasting eye color
  • Combats excess oil so that your eyelids don't look greasy
  • Perfect for when you need all-day, all-night staying power

Features

bareMinerals' Prime Time Eye Primer, like other eye primers, is applied to the eyelid before the application of shadow or eyeliner. It's a long-lasting primer that's great to use if you're planning an extended day at work or any special occasion. Its creamy formula resists excess oily buildup that can smudge and reduce the vibrancy of your makeup. It applies without a greasy finish, which is an added benefit.

Pros

  • Long-lasting primer
  • Resists excess oil buildup on the eyelid
  • Applies without a greasy finish

Cons

  • Must apply liberally
  • Small amount of product for price
  • price

This product can be found on Amazon for around from $15.05 to $20.00.

Features

A small amount of Mary Kay Eye Primer is enough to ensure your eyeshadow stays bright and colorful all day long. It's a popular choice for many who have sensitive and oily skin. Some users, left disappointed with other brands, claim this primer is one of the best they've tried. The Mary Kay Eye Primer helps increase the longevity of eyeshadow and enhances color vibrancy.

Pros

  • Prevents eye color from creasing or smudging
  • Suitable for sensitive eye area
  • Enhances shadow color vibrancy

Cons

  • Primer requires a longer set time
  • Slightly water consistency
  • price

This product can be found on Amazon for around from $15.00 to $25.00.

Features

The Urban Decay Eyeshadow Primer is well-known on the market as one of the best eyeshadow primers available. It does what it promises and lives up to all the hype. The formula is available in varying shades including champagne, gold, and matte tawny color. It also quickly absorbs into the skin, leaving a perfect finish. Urban Decay extends your makeup for hours. It's hard not to conclude that this eyeshadow primer is anything but the best on the market.

Pros

  • Formula is available in multiple shades
  • Fast absorbing and spreads evenly
  • An eyeshadow primer with great results

Cons

  • Expensive
  • Slightly thick consistency
  • price

This product can be found on Amazon for around from $27.80 to $30.00.

LORAC Behind The Scenes Eye Shadow Primer
  • Oil, fragrance and paraben free
  • Anti crease formula
  • Increase longevity of eye shadow

Features

LORAC Behind the Scenes Eye Shadow Primer applies easily and dries instantly. It only requires a small amount, applied to your shadow brush, for application. Rub, dab, or pat it over your eyelid as it spreads and dries quickly. LORAC eye primer is one of the best eyeshadow primers on the market, and you'll find it does an amazing job of brightening your eyes and locking in shadow to prevent creasing or smudging. It's a great product for all skin types, including oily skin.

Pros

  • Primer formula is lightweight, oil-free, and paraben-free
  • Locks in color for long-lasting, crease-resistant, vibrant makeup color
  • It applies easily

Cons

  • Slightly pricey
  • May cause the eyelid to feel slightly dry
  • Other 24-hour primers may offer longer result
  • price

This product can be found on Amazon for around from $23.00 to $25.00.

Laura Mercier Eye Basics - Wheat 5.1g/0.18oz
  • For Women
  • Image shown may not be true representation for size of this product, please refer to the size stated in the above...
  • Eye Basics - Wheat

Features

Laura Mercier Eye Basics eyeshadow primer comes in eight shades that include cotton, linen, and buff. It offers concealing benefits that ensure it covers all blemishes before shadow application. Formula ingredients include vitamin A, C, E, and a special Eye Bright complex to soothe irritated skin. Its sheer formula will lock in color so it is long-lasting while offering anti-aging nutrients.

Pros

  • Formula is available in multiple shades
  • Formula ingredients include vitamin A, C, E
  • Soothes irritated skin

Cons

  • Pricey
  • A little difficult to apply
  • price

This product can be found on Amazon for around from $28.00 to $30.00.

SMASHBOX Photo Finish Hydrating Under Eye & 24 Hour Shadow Primer -...
  • Photo Finish 24 Hour Shadow Primer 4ml
  • Hydrating Under Eye Primer 5ml

Features

Smashbox Photo Finish Shadow Primer is excellent. It will lock in your eye makeup and ensure it stays exactly in place. You will notice upon removing your makeup that your shadow appearance is exactly the same as it was in the morning. For many with oily skin, this primer will ensure that your shadow and liner stays vibrant and long-lasting. It's even strong enough to survive an intense workout. What more could anyone ask for?

Pros

  • Maximizes color vibrancy
  • Prevents fading or smudging
  • One of the best eyeshadow primers for oily skin

Cons

  • A thick consistency
  • A slightly small volume of formula
  • price

This product can be found on Amazon for around from $20.00 to $25.00.

Comparison Table

Product

Product Details

Price & Rating

Size

0.25 Ounce

Item Weight

0.32 ounces

Product Dimentions

1.3 x 1.3 x 1.1 inches

Size

2 sizes: 0.35 oz / 2-pack

Item Weight

0.32 ounces

Product Dimentions

1.1 x 1.1 x 4.5 inches

Size

0.35 Ounce

Item Weight

0.96 ounces

Product Dimentions

0.8 x 1.2 x 6.9 inches

Size

Eye Primer (10G)

Item Weight

0.48 ounces

Product Dimentions

3.4 x 1.5 x 0.5 inches

Size

0.1 Ounce

Item Weight

1.9 pounds

Product Dimentions

 2 x 1.5 x 4.5 inches 

Size

-

Item Weight

0.8 ounces

Product Dimentions

3 x 4 x 5 inches

Size

0.33 fl. oz./10 ml

Item Weight

1.6 ounces

Product Dimentions

-

Size

-

Item Weight

 0.8 ounces

Product Dimentions

0.9 x 0.9 x 4.4 inches

Size

5.1g/0.18oz

Item Weight

0.32 ounces

Product Dimentions

0.8 x 0.9 x 3.8 inches

Size

0.41 Fluid Ounce

Item Weight

1 pounds

Product Dimentions

1 x 1 x 5 inches

The Verdict

For the price, the result, and for a long-lasting hold on shadow and liner, the Smashbox 24 Hour Photo Finish Shadow Primer is the best of the list! It delivers exactly what it promises, ensuring and maximizing color vibrancy, preventing fading, creasing, and smudging; it even holds up against oily buildup. Other eyeshadow primers on our list are hardly inferior products. So, if you're looking for an eye primer with a slightly lower price or with different qualities, reconsider other competing brands listed here. You won't be disappointed!