Finding the best maple syrup that suits your palate and provides you with adequate nutrients may seem challenging, but knowing what to look for can help you make a better decision. To help you out further and to make your choices easier, we’ve put together a list of the ten best maple syrups in 2018 in this guide. Read on to find out how they compare with one another.
 

Maple Syrup FAQ

Before you go further and look for the best maple syrup money can buy, you may want to understand and explore the answers to some of the most frequently asked questions about maple syrup. This can help you make an informed decision.

1. What Is Maple Syrup?

2. How Can Maple Syrup Be Used?

3. What Are the Health Benefits of Maple Syrup?

4. What Are Some Factors to Consider When Looking for the Best Maple Syrup?

5. Where Can You Buy the Best Maple Syrup?

How We Reviewed

We combed through several online marketplaces and evaluated the maple syrup offered by various brands based on factors like grades, taste, user opinions, and the ingredients used. We then picked the ten best maple syrups from among the many options available and reviewed them based on parameters including features, pros and cons, price and grade.
 

Overall Price Range of the Best Maple Syrup

The overall price range of the best maple syrups lies between $20 to $30 for a 32-ounce jar. Some brands may offer their maple syrup at a discount while others may sell the product at a much higher price. It’s advisable to set less store by price and prioritize the quality of the syrup above all else.

What We Reviewed

  • Nova Maple Syrup
  • Anderson's Pure Maple Syrup
  • Butternut Mountain Farm 100% Pure Organic Maple Syrup
  • Canadian Finest Maple Syrup
  • Hidden Springs Organic Vermont Maple Syrup
  • Coombs Family Farms Organic Maple Syrup
  • Barred Woods Pure Vermont Maple Syrup 
  • Ben’s Sugar Shack Pure Maple Syrup
  • Uncle Luke's 100% Pure Maple Syrup
  • NOW Foods Organic Maple Syrup
Nova Maple Syrup - Pure Grade-A Maple Syrup (Pint)
  • 100% Pure, all natural, maple syrup
  • Grade A - Best flavor and color available. Harvested and made in the USA
  • Made from 100% real maple sap. No chemicals, preservatives, artificial flavors, colors, or other additives

Features

What sets Nova Maple Syrup apart from other brands is that it’s not mass-produced. Rather, the sap used for this syrup is sustainably harvested from hardwood forests in Pennsylvania, and solar power is mostly used to develop the syrup.

Pros

  • The quality of the syrup is superior, and it shows that in the taste
  • Does not include any chemicals, artificial flavors or colors, preservatives or additives

Cons

  • Consistency may be a bit thinner than the maple syrups offered by some other brands
  • The flavor isn’t exactly impressive

Price

A pint of this maple syrup can be purchased on Amazon for around $12 or less.

Grade

This maple syrup from Nova is pure grade A syrup.

Anderson's Pure Maple Syrup, Grade A Very Dark/Grade B, 32 Ounce...
  • Grade A Very Dark / Grade B is great as a cooking additive to sweeten up many different foods
  • Store In Cool Dry Place
  • Grade A Very Dark / Grade B Syrup is the same syrup as what our Grade B was - we've just changed the name to match the...

Features

Loaded with numerous antioxidants and boasting of a low glycemic index, this jar of pure maple syrup from Anderson’s comes wrapped up in frustration-free packaging, which basically means that it’s all recyclable. Additionally, the syrup is 100 percent natural and has versatile uses.

Pros

  • The syrup is of superior quality and rich in its consistency
  • Perfect for people who prefer maple syrup that has a deep and rich flavor
  • The syrup isn’t very sticky, so it’s easy to use it all up till the very last drop

Cons

  • The flavor may be too strong for some
  • The syrup leaves a strong after-taste

Price

A 32-ounce bottle of maple syrup from Anderson’s can be purchased on Amazon for around $24 or less.

Grade

This maple syrup from Anderson’s is labeled as “grade A very dark” with a strong taste.

Butternut Mountain Farm 100% Pure Organic Maple Syrup From Vermont,...
  • FLAVOR PROFILE: The darker the syrup, the stronger the flavor. Our Grade A Dark Color, Robust Taste maple syrup is the...
  • SUSTAINABLY SOURCED: At Butternut Mountain Farm we are committed to giving you 100% pure Vermont maple syrup. The...
  • QUALITY STORY: Our pure maple syrup is carefully selected to ensure the product you receive is of the highest quality....

Features

This pure maple syrup has been produced from the sap of maple trees tapped in Vermont and comes in BPA-free, easy-squeeze bottles that have a silicon valve to keep the syrup from dripping and dribbling. The bottle is also easy to store as it takes up less space and can easily fit in the door of your fridge.

Pros

  • Has a nice, robust flavor with subtly complex layers
  • Leaves a pleasant aftertaste
  • 100 percent pure syrup contains no preservatives, artificial colors or flavors 

Cons

  • Some users reported they received broken or damaged bottles
  • The consistency may be on the thinner side

Price

A 12-fluid-ounce bottle of this maple syrup from Butternut Mountain Farm can be purchased on Amazon for around $10 or less.

Grade

This maple syrup from Butternut Mountain Farm is labeled as “grade A dark” with a robust taste.

CANADIAN FINEST Maple Syrup | #1 Rated Maple Syrup on Amazon - 100%...
  • THE BEST MAPLE SYRUP YOU'VE EVER TASTED - Nothing comes close to maple syrup from Canada, and Canadian Finest is the...
  • CERTIFIED ORGANIC, 100% NATURAL GOODNESS - Canadian Finest is 100% pure, Certified Organic maple syrup that contains no...
  • THE BEST MAPLE SYRUP IN THE WORLD COMES FROM CANADA - When you think of Canada, you probably think of polite people who...

Features

This maple syrup has been harvested from trees in Quebec, Canada and is certified as 100 percent pure and organic. It contains no chemicals, preservatives, or additives, and needs to be refrigerated after you’ve opened it.

Pros

  • The flavor has a distinct taste that sets it apart from most other maple syrup brands
  • The consistency is ideal as it’s neither too thick nor too watery
  • Widely touted as the best maple syrup available online
  • The syrup is dark, robust and isn’t adulterated with other ingredients like corn syrup

Cons

  • The taste may be a bit too sweet for some people
  • Slightly more expensive than other brands of maple syrup

Price

A 16.9-ounce bottle of this maple syrup from Canadian Finest can be purchased on Amazon for around $19 to $30.

Grade

This maple syrup from Canadian Finest is labeled as “grade A dark” with a robust taste.

Hidden Springs Organic Vermont Maple Syrup, Grade A Dark Robust...
  • CERTIFIED ORGANIC: By Vermont Organic Farmers LLC (VOF). Guaranteeing you and your family a healthier product, sourced...
  • DARK COLOR WITH ROBUST FLAVOR: Good for all around use, its hearty flavor is a great choice for all kinds of recipes....
  • HANDCRAFTED VERMONT SYRUP: All of our syrup comes from organic family farms in Vermont.

Features

Certified as kosher and organic by Vermont Organic Farmers LLC, this maple syrup meets all the requirements set for grade A dark syrup. It’s harvested from family farms in Vermont and delivered in BPA-free plastic jugs that are sturdy and durable.

Pros

  • The taste is distinct and rich, consistent across batches
  • The texture and consistency of the syrup is just right
  • Smooth on the palate and does not leave any bitter aftertaste

Cons

  • The taste may not be for everyone
  • Some users reported having received a bottle of expired maple syrup

Price

A 16-ounce bottle of maple syrup from Hidden Springs Maple can be purchased on Amazon for around $14 to $25.

Grade

This maple syrup from Hidden Springs Maple is labeled as “grade A dark” with a robust taste.

Coombs Family Farms Maple Syrup, Organic, Grade A, Dark Color, Robust...
  • One, 32-ounce jug
  • Premium Grade B maple syrup
  • Certified Kosher; certified organic by QAI

Features

Certified as kosher and as organic by QAI, this maple syrup is sourced from small, family-run farms that use no pesticides. It contains no artificial dyes, preservatives or favors, and it also comes in packaging that is frustration-free.

Pros

  • Features an excellent balance of flavors that makes the taste distinct and pleasant
  • Has the most zest when compared with several other similar syrups
  • Entirely maple, it doesn’t include any additional flavors

Cons

  • Its aftertaste may not be for everyone
  • Sweetness may be a little too high for some

Price

A 32-ounce jug of maple syrup from Coombs Family Farms can be purchased on Amazon for around $25 or less.

Grade

This maple syrup from Coombs Family Farms is labeled as “grade A dark” with a robust taste.

Pure Vermont Maple Syrup - One Pint Jug (16 oz) - Grade A Amber Rich -...
  • Best Tasting, All Natural 100% Pure Vermont Maple Syrup. Healthy and Delicious!
  • Straight from the Producer - From Our Trees to Your Table
  • From the Heart of Maple Syrup Country in Northern Vermont

Features

Produced in small batches and developed with great focus on quality and purity, this maple syrup from Barred Woods Maple comes packed in FDA-approved plastic jugs with caps that are tamper-proof. It’s extracted from maple trees in Northern Vermont, and comes straight from the producer to your table with no added artificial ingredients.

Pros

  • The taste is strong yet sweet and features a perfect balance of flavors
  • Flavor is richer than that of typical maple syrup
  • It’s all natural and has no artificial components added

Cons

  • Not as popular as other maple syrup brands
  • The aftertaste may not be preferred by some people

Price

A 16-ounce bottle of this maple syrup from Barred Woods Maple can be purchased on Amazon for around $13 to $23.

Grade

This maple syrup from Barred Woods Maple is labeled as “grade A amber” with a rich taste.

Ben's Sugar Shack, Grade A Dark Amber, of Pure Maple Syrup Award...
  • 100% of pure maple syrup; The maple syrup grading system is based on syrup color and was established by the USDA

Features

Endowed with various certifications like kosher, pareve, nut-free, gluten-free, 100 percent natural, and non-GMO, this maple syrup is as healthy as it is tasty. It combines great flavor with a reasonable price giving you the best of both worlds.

Pros

  • More affordable than the maple syrup from most other brands
  • Of excellent quality that remains consistent across batches
  • Not diluted with other ingredients like corn syrup

Cons

  • Its taste may be a bit weird and its consistency thick for people who aren’t used to strong syrup
  • The bottle doesn’t include the grade according to the new system

Price

A 32-ounce bottle of this maple syrup from Ben’s Sugar Shack can be purchased on Amazon for around $18 or less.

Grade

This maple syrup from Ben’s Sugar Shack is labeled as “grade A dark amber” in the old grading system.

Features

With several impressive assertions like gluten-free formulation and a flavor that’s grade A amber with a rich taste, this maple syrup from Uncle Luke’s is 100 percent pure and natural, and is sourced from maple trees grown in Canada’s best regions.

Pros

  • This syrup offers an unbeatable combination of great taste at a great price
  • The bottle is easy to carry and store
  • The syrup is darker than similar products and is ideal for those who prefer a rich taste

Cons

  • The consistency runs a bit thinner than that of typical maple syrup
  • The flavor may seem a bit odd to some

Price

A 32-ounce bottle of this maple syrup from Uncle Luke’s can be purchased on Amazon for around $30 to $40.

Grade

This maple syrup from Uncle Luke’s is labeled as “grade A amber” with a rich taste.

NOW Foods Organic Maple Syrup,Grade A Amber Color, 32-Ounce
  • ORGANIC, GRADE A, AMBER MAPLE SYRUP: Perfect for adding to pancakes, yogurt, ice cream, oatmeal, recipes, and more.
  • PURE, RICH TASTE: Grade A Amber Color Maple Syrup has a lighter, more delicate flavor than Grade A Dark Color Maple...
  • CERTIFICATIONS/CLASSIFICATIONS: Non-GMO Project Verified, USDA Certified Organic, Paleo Friendly, Vegan/Vegetarian, Made...

Features

NOW Foods produces an organic maple syrup that is kosher, gluten-free, vegan and vegetarian, and includes no GMOs. It’s paleo-friendly and developed by a family-owned business that pays great attention to quality and purity.

Pros

  • Rich in nutrients and great for people interested in eliminating artificial sugars from their diet
  • Pairs well with many foods, from breakfasts to beverages
  • Contains no imitating ingredients like corn syrup

Cons

  • Some users reported they received a damaged package
  • The taste may be a bit mild for people who like their syrup strong and rich

Price

A 32-ounce bottle of maple syrup from NOW Foods can be purchased on Amazon for around $20 to $30.

Grade

This maple syrup from NOW Foods is labeled as “grade A medium amber” according to the old grading system, which translates to “grade A amber” with a rich taste according to the new system.

Comparison Table

Product

Product Details

Price & Rating

Size

-

Item Weight

1.5 pounds

Product Dimentions

3 x 3 x 6 inches

Size

32 Ounce 

Item Weight

3 pounds

Product Dimentions

5.4 x 5.4 x 8.8 inches

Size

12 Fl Oz

Item Weight

12 ounces

Product Dimentions

7 x 2 x 3 inches

Size

16.9 fl oz (500mL)

Item Weight

-

Product Dimentions

3.1 x 3.1 x 6.6 inches

Size

16 Ounce

Item Weight

1 pounds

Product Dimentions

-

Size

32 Ounce

Item Weight

2.2 pounds

Product Dimentions

-

Size

16 oz

Item Weight

-

Product Dimentions

4 x 4 x 6 inches

Size

946 ml

Item Weight

2.95 pounds

Product Dimentions

-

Size

32 Ounce

Item Weight

2 pounds

Product Dimentions

-

Size

32-Ounce

Item Weight

3.05 pounds

Product Dimentions

6 x 5 x 4 inches

The Verdict

All the maple syrups we chose are 100 percent natural and pure, yet they each have their own special characteristics. The winner must be picked, however, and the syrup from Coombs Family Farms may just be the best maple syrup you can have the pleasure to enjoy. It’s dark and robust, and the best part is that it complements just about every kind of food. Other good options for dark and robust maple syrup include the ones from Butternut Mountain Farm, Hidden Springs Maple and Canadian Finest. If you prefer a syrup that is deep and rich in flavor, stronger and less sugary, the “grade A very dark” maple syrup from Anderson’s may be just what you’re looking for.